Mutter(Peas) Paneer with Tikka masala

There are several paneer recipes on my blog.  I am always trying out new variations of mutter paneer and often the taste is guided by the taste of my children.  This recipe was made at the request of my son and he wanted me to use plenty of double cream in the dish. Using home made paneer made this dish taste great. Paneer is home-made, unsalted, white cheese. It has a fresh quality and a dense, crumbly texture that goes beautifully with strong flavors.

Ingredients (serves 4):

  • 4 cups Home made paneer :(If using store bought paneer try and look for softer version of paneer)
  • I cup green peas (fresh or frozen)
  • 2 tsp ready made Patak’s tikka masala paste
  • 1 cup natural yoghurt
  • 1 teaspoon of grated ginger (or use the cubes of frozen chillies, ginger and garlic)
  • 2-3 cloves of freshly minced garlic
  • 2-3 green chillies cut finely
  • 1 teaspoon of mustard seeds
  • half teaspoon turmeric powder
  • ½ cup  cashewnuts, powdered
  • 1 cup of Pasatta
  • ½ cup of double cream
  • Small bunch of chopped coriander leaves
  • ½ cup sunflower oil or similar
  • 2 tablespoons lemon juice
  • 2 teaspoons sugar or sugar substitute
  • Salt to taste


1. Cut the paneer into half inch  strips and then cubes
2.  Mix 2-3 teaspoons of the paneer tikka masala to the yogurt and pour it on the paneer cubes.  Mix well.  If using home made paneer, be gentle as you don’t want the cubes to start breaking.  Allow this mixture to marinate at least 30 minutes.
3.  Cover a baking tray with aluminium foil, brush  some oil on the foil and arrange the cubes on the tray.  Allow for some gap between the cubes. If you have any of the marinade left over, save it to add to the curry.
4.  Cook these in the oven  at 160 degrees Centigrade (Gas mark 3 or 325 F)  for 15 minutes.  If the paneer hasn’t browned a bit at the sides, give it a couple of minutes more.
5. Allow the paneer cubes to cool.
6. Prepare the sauce.  Heat 2 tablespoons of oil and add the mustard seeds to the oil. Once the mustard seeds stop popping, add the pasatta and stir.  Add in the blended ginger, garlic and chillies; the salt, lemon and sugar.  Also add in the peas  and allow to cook for 5-6 minutes – giving you time to remove the paneer cubes from the tray.
 7.  Add the paneer cubes to the curry.  Also add in any left over marinade sauce mixture at this stage.  Allow the mixture to simmer gently.
8.  Add the powdered cashews to the curry and stir.
9. Once the sauce looks nice and thick, add in the double cream slowly , stirring in between.
10.  Allow the curry to simmer on a low heat until the sauce is nice and thick.
11.  Remove  and garnish it with coriander and some more cream.
12.  Serve with hot chappatis or naan bread.
  • The gravy looks fabulous & mouthwatering!!!! Must try this out!!
    Prathima Rao
    Prats Corner

  • wow.. making me hungry….

  • This is very much delicious. Last day we were discussing about Paneer tikka on Pizza:) And today you posted the recipe:))Must try once.

  • wow this looks scrumptiously delicious

  • deliciously done dish

  • Wow Mina, what a rocking recipe!!! Bookmarking it right away!!! I can already tell it’s gobsmacking delish.

    What’s Pasatta?

  • Mina, gravy looks nice & creamy also liked the idea to add bake the paneer with masala, definitely adds alot of flavor

  • So creamy and delicious..loved your yummy version!

  • All time favourite..Perfectly made..

  • Who will resist to this irresistible mutter paneer, inviting.

  • Hi Mina,
    The curry looks just the colour of the gravy…just like the restaurant.would love this with naans.

  • That is an elaborately prepared dish and I am sure the taste would differ too as compared to the quick methods I use in my paneer curry. Looks delicious.

  • Awesome dish dear.. i love the way u prepared it…

  • Delicious.. I just had it for my dinner..

  • Paneer tikka masala looks delicious…..u done perfectly…..

  • looks so healthy & delicious…mouthwatering!

  • Delicious delight, Nice clicks.

  • Creamy yummy curry…Happy to follow you…And will br glad if u do so….

  • You photos are delicious in themselves. Great blog!

%d bloggers like this: